LoJo,
I have been a fan of yours for a long time, and it is great to have your input on this highly debated issue. I have enjoyed checking out your new website.
I am trying to clarify for my own understanding, and for that of other readers of these forums.
While I agree that the bottom arm should not collapse immediately or completely, I have to respond to your comments about Bubka's bottom arm. The best source of information I have regarding Bubka's intent comes from his coach, Petrov. According to his own words (via a translator), Petrov believes that there is an advantage to be gained by flexing the bottom arm out after the takeoff is complete. In his speech in Reno from 2005, Petrov is clear that the bottom arm should be completely straight and strong at the plant, @90 degrees to the pole, but that it should flex outward after the initial upward push, allowing the vaulters chest to drive forward and chase the pole, as the bottom hand comes over the head. He asserts that this gives the ability to swing the whole body through the top hand up over the top of the pole, instead of swinging up beneath the pole.
Petrov's speech in Reno in 2005, paraphrased:
"...take off through the left hand, and after that, you load the right hand..."
"...after the initial push upward, you need to focus on the energy coming forward, so you should bend the left arm up to 90 degrees..."
"...(translator:) he is strong about it, you cannot hold the left hand straight after the takeoff, if you do the swing is going to be from the bottom instead of from the whole body..."
"...if you keep the bottom arm straight after the takeoff it will result in a low swing..."
The whole speech is great, but the discussion I referenced starts at 45 minutes or so.
http://youtu.be/bMUQaWfAx48I know that it is possible to achieve the right position after takeoff with full bottom arm pressure, but most kids with low grips who try this are not going to get much benefit, imho. Perhaps your comments assume that kids can learn to be rigid in the elbows, but elastic in the shoulders? I agree, but isn't it easier to teach a straight bottom arm as the vaulter advances, the step comes out, and the grip goes up; rather than trying to fix a blocked swing?
Tom