MadeinTaiwan wrote:Horseshit - we routinely "cap" poles all the time and have no problem with breakage.
I wasn't stating it as a fact, I was asking a question.
What i really wanted to know was, since sail pieces are designed to redirect stress throughout the whole pole, I am guessing they work best when the pole is held at a certain height in relation to the poles length, I was just wondering if anybody could tell me what is too low and if there is a "too high"(unless thats "horseshit")
Thanks
Yeah, I know you were asking a question - my comment wasn't directed at you. It's the handhold band rule they came up with, which, I understand, was a safety thing to try to prevent high schoolers from gripping too high, overbending poles, and either getting launched off the back of the pit or breaking them. What it doesn't take into account though, is that you could be holding 2 feet down on the pole and STILL be holding too HIGH OR be capping a pole and still holding too LOW - grip should be determined by where you're landing and how much the pole is bending. Even the manufacturers don't agree, so Gill's max handhold band is about 3-4" from the top, currently Essx is about the same, but used to be 1" from the top, Spirit is 6" from the top, Altius just added more pole to the end so you could hold at the top (ie: 13'3, 14'3, 15'3).
I personally feel that 90% of poles work best when held the top, provided you're not overgripping for your ability. Another coach I know feels that Essx poles have a sensitive threshold about 3-6" from the top where they just mush out and don't respond, regardless of stiffness because there is much less glass in the top of the pole than at the bottom. (I'm sure Bruce will chime in here

)
I do think there is a too low, and it varies from pole to pole, length to length, brand to brand, depending on if they have a sailpiece (many small poles do not), the shape of the sail, and its location. We generally don't grip anyone down more than 16" from the top, or we'll simply go down a length on pole size. They just tend to be a bit too twitchy gripping below that.