Unread postby vaultdad » Sat Feb 14, 2004 3:08 am
I've thought about the helmet issue a lot, and I don't mean to encourage or detract from wearing a helmet while vaulting but here are my thoughts.
I was seriously saddened by Kevin Dares passing, but I have to wonder:
If something happened in his head when he was upside down that essentially ended his life, before the fall. We'll never really know.
If it would have been so sensational had he been swimming,playing lacrosse or tennis at the time. Most of the research I've done has shown that most fatal injuries have been due to stuff outside the immediate pit area that should not have been there at all. Concrete, Asphalt, rubberized asphalt, pallets, and rocks are not human friendly, but somehow show up a lot! I don't let anyone leave stuff around the pit if I'm running the event. You guys and gals can come down quite a ways from the box if the plant goes wrong. There's no need to add insult to injury.
Iwonder if anyone realizes how unlikely it was that a helmet would have saved Kevin's life from that height. Humans are really fragile, even though we sometimes don't want to think so. If the helmet saved his head from a fracture, but his neck vertebrae or spinal cord were still seriously damaged the result could have easily been the same. Some studies have shown the wrong helmet shape could encourage neck damage. I think the Softbox is a major improvement in vaulting safety, but I still think the physics of the event as they transpired would still have killed Kevin. At the very least, he could have still gotten a brain bruise and serious swelling even with the soft vaultbox. I also think the official could have possibly pushed him onto the pads, and maybe given him better odds of surviving, but it apparently didn't happen either. I don't know how NCAA officals feel about doing it, and I didn't see it so I have no idea what really happened.
If a helmet gives you more confidence, find a good one to practice in, and get comfortable with it. If you're getting one because you're already scaring yourself or folks around you, the helmet might make your parents or next of kin more comfortable, but you should probably reevaluate your skills first before you really hurt yourself. Sorry about the long post.
Vaulting Incognito "I saw those tubes on your truck, and I thought you were a plumber . . ."